Disqualification of Judges article

Michael G. Loeffler’s recent article in the California Lawyers Association publication Family Law News discusses little-known approaches to the disqualification of judges.

Click here for a reproduction of this article.

From the introduction:

There is a fascinating but largely unknown procedure in the Code of Civil Procedure for  disqualification of judges. The purpose of this article is to educate the legal community about this subject.

When lawyers and judges think about the subject of disqualifying a judge, most of us immediately focus on Code of Civil Procedure section 170.6 procedure at the beginning of a case.

However, can you disqualify a judge for cause after the initial pleading stage? Surprisingly, yes.

Does Fair Have Anything To Do With It?

Michael G. Loeffler’s recent article in the California Lawyers Association publication Family Law News discusses the nuances of “fairness” in family law.

Click here for a reproduction of this article.

Despite family law courts being courts of equity, the California Family Code is not based on fairness.  Clint Eastwood once said, “Fair’s got nothing to do with it.” Perhaps that is as it should be.

This article has two main points:

  • In some instances, the courts’ current practices in administering the Domestic Violence Protection Act (DVPA) end up with a result that one might consider unfair from an economic standpoint.
  • Additionally, the same court practices sometimes result in orders that are not in the best interests of children.

Both the Family Code and case law emphasize that the court’s first priority is to ensure “the best interests of the child” and that this should normally include frequent and continuing contact by both parents.  Additionally, there is a strong statutory intent in taking appropriate steps to stop domestic violence. In recent years, the term “domestic violence” has been expanded. “Domestic violence” under the Family Code, unlike the Penal Code, is defined as, among other actions, anything that “disturbs one’s emotional calm.”

The reality is that these interests sometimes conflict in DVPA proceedings….

How to Set the Table

Michael Loeffler outlines the steps lawyers should take when starting a family law case in an article entitled “How To Set The Table.”  Potential clients may benefit from reviewing it before your first meeting.

From the introduction:

You are at the beginning of a case. What steps should you take?

There are many articles on the subject of what to advise clients at your first interview. What follows are some different ideas typically not mentioned there. Caveat:  this is not intended to be all-inclusive. Nor is this intended to be advice. However, these points may be useful to you as part of a checklist….


Call Now Button